Skip to main content

HS Surjeet - the late & the communists



One of two patriarchal figures of the Indian communist movements has passed on and that leaves Jyoti Basu as the last surviving leader. While my knowledge of political history especially that pertaining to the sixties is limited I remember my late father used to keep showing his irritation whenever they showed this gentleman on TV. He kept saying - "what has this old fellow done in politics that he is given so much importance". Many have talked about how he supported the Chinese but then I think the Indian communist movement has never really cut its umblical cord with China. The support for China has been blatantly brazen at times and subdued at others but it has never ever gone away.

The last 4 years saw Karat and his ilk oppose everything and today if the Congress finds itself in a sorry state, it only has the Communists to blame for this. Now a days viewing TV news or reading a newspaper is easier on the blood pressure. We dont see these hypocritical communists occupy centre stage pontificating on everything under the sun with their holier than thou attitude. Talk about a bunch of negative minded people who if left to themselves would drag India into the cavemen era. It is nobodys argument that the capaitalistic economy is without any flaws and perfect or that communism is negative and imperfect. But Karat and his henchmen have managed to create a hugely negative image of communism by their "opposing everything" attitude.

The state of Kerala's industry is there for everyone to see. Today barring for tourism and some government organisations like ISRO, Kerala has lost almost its entire industrial segment, thanks to the belligerant attitude of these same communists. And to think that elsewhere in the world Keralites are known for their hard and sincere work. Ever see a hospital without Keralite nurses ??? Bengal is not far behind and thanks to Bhattacharya trying to be a bit pragmatic this state seems to be inching towards some progress.

The latest issue of India Today sums it up well when it says that these days the leaders are accumalating frequent flier miles as they try to explain their action against Somnath Chatterjee since no TV studio is inviting them. Good riddance is what I say - who wants to listen to their sound bytes.

The action of Karat in suspending Somnath shows what a poor leader he is and how out of touch he is with the modern young India. When young India is so much disillusioned with its political class for its behaviour, Somnath managed to uphold the prestige of the Speakers chair by refusing to align himself to his political beliefs and did not resign. If he had resigned as instructed by Karat, the damage done to the Speakers position would have been immense and would have created a precedence for future.

It is a matter of time before Mayawati shows her Maya and makes Karat irrelevant as she showed within a couple of days by stealing the thunder and spotlight away from Karat even as the no confidence motion was underway.

The biggest tragedy is that after having visited China and seen first hand the development and progress, I fail to fathom why the Indian communists are in a time warp of their own. I still remember a Chinese colleague asking me why progress in India was so slow and whether democracy was to blame. I told him that democracy certainly slowed things down but it ensured that all sections of society were carried forward together but if we were lagging far behind China it was because China only has communism but India had communists !!!! Now thankfully we are spared of this millstone round our neck.

Cheers

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The INDI Alliance has indeed won !!!!

Quite a long time back when I first got the opportunity to sit in a company board meeting, I noticed the Chairman making a strange remark as he opened the board meeting. He used to say something like ā€“ ā€œPlease unhide your hidden agendas and keep your vested interests outsideā€. Young, intrigued I finally summoned enough courage to understand this from some other seniors and got a lesson I have never forgotten. He said that be it a person or an organisation, in many a situation, they have a stated intent and a real intent. Meaning that when they approach a situation, they explain what is their intent which would be more popular, acceptable and palatable to the audience but the real intent could well be very different. Most likely the real intent would be self-defeating or unpopular. In this just concluded election for the Lok Sabha we saw this happening in full flow and to my mind the BJP likely missed reading the message. It is not as if I have some inside information but am using log...

The Trump Victory

The Defining Moment in POTUS 2024 Elections Enough and more is being debated and discussed about the victory of Donald Trump in the USA Presidential elections. Here is my take on the issue. Before the elections, one felt that Trump had a chance but given his unpredictable behaviour, was most likely to lose. Further, it was obvious that the left socialist deep state did not want him in the White House. The popular expectation was that the deep state would use the election system to legally rig the vote in favour of the democrats. With Joe Biden as the opponent, his chances were optimistic. Then suddenly Joe Biden nominated Kamala Harris in his place and walked away into the sunset. At that time ā€“ she had everything that was perfect based on what we heard/read ā€“ Black, Woman, Active proponent of LGBTQ, Abortion etc. Soon the Hollywood glitterati and Silicon Valley corporate honchos officially endorsed her. Given the long line up of big names, a very partial list here, her winning was a f...

Review of Budget 2025 in Advance

A largely facetious, partly serious take on the impending Budget 2025 - stated for tomorrow. For a start, one can print the reactions of the various voices to any budget in bulk and simply rehash it every year. They are so predictable that the only person who can say something different is Shashi Tharoor because he will use new words that make you think he is saying something different. The other would be Suhel Seth. He takes on various people right from correcting their grammar and spellings to his hilarious responses in his trademark style. Unlike Shashi, Suhel uses Shakespearian English to insult the political folks, and they donā€™t even realise they are being insulted. That said here are a few typical comments that will come from the opposition, and these are a collection since the 80ā€™s when I first heard what a budget was. Obviously in 40+ years nothing has changed, and I share my own comments in italics and red against some of the comments. If any budget is not for development an...